MesaLabs
  • Our Solutions

    • Sterilization & Cleaning Monitoring

      • Products

        • Biological Indicators & Accessories

        • Chemical Indicators

        • Cleaning Control

        • All Products

      • Services & Consulting

        • Sterilization Cycle Development & Validation

        • Contract Laboratory Testing

      • Knowledge Center

        • Resource Library

        • White Papers

        • Training & Events

        • Videos

        • FAQs

        • Customer Support

        • Request a Quote

    • Mail-in Spore Testing

      • Products

        • Testing Services Packages

        • In-Office Testing Products

        • Chemical Indicators

        • All Products

      • Services

        • Check Test Results

      • Knowledge Center

        • State Dental Regulations

        • Industry Insights

        • FAQs

        • Customer Support

      • Shop Online

    • Continuous & Process Monitoring

      • Hardware

        • Continuous Monitoring Panels & Sensors

        • Process Monitoring Data Loggers

        • All Products

      • Software

        • Continuous Monitoring Software

        • Continuous Monitoring Software Downloads

        • Process Monitoring Software

      • Services

        • Validation & Calibration Services

        • Data Logger Calibration & Repair

      • Knowledge Center

        • Resource Library

        • FAQs

        • Customer Support

        • Request a Quote

      • Shop Online

    • Renal Care Quality Control

      • Products

        • 90XL Technician Meter

        • pHoenix XL Reference Meter

        • Solutions - Conductivity, pH, Neo Care, NIST-Traceable

        • Care & Calibration Stations

        • All Products

      • Services

        • Equipment Calibration & Repair

      • Knowledge Center

        • Resource Library

        • FAQs

        • Customer Support

        • Request a Quote

      • Shop Online

    • Occupational Health & Safety

      • Gas & Air Flow Instruments

        • Mesa Defender Series (Volumetric Accuracy ±1%)

        • Mesa FlexCal Series (Volumetric Accuracy ±0.5%)

        • Mesa BGI DryCal Metrology Series

        • All Products

      • Accessories

        • Mesa Defender Series Accessories

        • Mesa FlexCal Series Accessories

        • Mesa DryCal Pro Software

      • Services

        • Equipment Calibration & Repair

      • Knowledge Center

        • Resource Library

        • Videos

        • FAQs

        • Customer Support

        • Request a Quote

      • Shop Online

    • Environmental Controls & Air Quality

      • Equipment

        • Mesa BGI Ambient Particulate Air Samplers

        • Mesa BGI Air Flow Calibrators

        • Mesa BGI Personal Sampling Cyclones

        • Mesa BGI Environmental Cyclones

        • All Products

      • Software

        • Mesa BGI Companion Software

      • Accessories

        • Environmental Accessories

        • Industrial Hygiene Accessories

        • Filter Media

      • Services

        • Equipment Calibration & Repair

        • Equipment Rental

      • Knowledge Center

        • Resource Library

        • Videos

        • FAQs

        • Customer Support

        • Request a Quote

      • Shop Online

    • Torque Testing

      • Products

        • Semi-Automatic Torque Testers

        • Manual Torque Testers

        • All Products

      • Accessories

        • Torque Testing Accesories

      • Software

        • TorqueIQ Process Control Software

      • Services

        • Gold Bottle Magnetic Torque Verification

        • Equipment Calibration & Repair

        • Upgrade/Trade-In Options

        • Torque Rentals

      • Knowledge Center

        • Resource Library

        • Customer Support

        • Request a Quote

  • About Us

    • Our Purpose

    • Mesa Brand Family

    • Executive Team

    • Careers

    • Investor Information

  • Contact Us

  • Resource Library

    • Certificate (COA) Finder

    • Regulatory Documents

    • Instruction Manuals

    • Product Specifications

    • Product Technical Reports

    • Safety Data Sheets

  • Our Solutions

    chevron
    • Sterilization & Cleaning Monitoring

      • Products

        • Biological Indicators & Accessories

        • Chemical Indicators

        • Cleaning Control

        • All Products

      • Services & Consulting

        • Sterilization Cycle Development & Validation

        • Contract Laboratory Testing

      • Knowledge Center

        • Resource Library

        • White Papers

        • Training & Events

        • Videos

        • FAQs

        • Customer Support

        • Request a Quote

    • Mail-in Spore Testing

      • Products

        • Testing Services Packages

        • In-Office Testing Products

        • Chemical Indicators

        • All Products

      • Services

        • Check Test Results

      • Knowledge Center

        • State Dental Regulations

        • Industry Insights

        • FAQs

        • Customer Support

      • Shop Online

    • Continuous & Process Monitoring

      • Hardware

        • Continuous Monitoring Panels & Sensors

        • Process Monitoring Data Loggers

        • All Products

      • Software

        • Continuous Monitoring Software

        • Continuous Monitoring Software Downloads

        • Process Monitoring Software

      • Services

        • Validation & Calibration Services

        • Data Logger Calibration & Repair

      • Knowledge Center

        • Resource Library

        • FAQs

        • Customer Support

        • Request a Quote

      • Shop Online

    • Renal Care Quality Control

      • Products

        • 90XL Technician Meter

        • pHoenix XL Reference Meter

        • Solutions - Conductivity, pH, Neo Care, NIST-Traceable

        • Care & Calibration Stations

        • All Products

      • Services

        • Equipment Calibration & Repair

      • Knowledge Center

        • Resource Library

        • FAQs

        • Customer Support

        • Request a Quote

      • Shop Online

    • Occupational Health & Safety

      • Gas & Air Flow Instruments

        • Mesa Defender Series (Volumetric Accuracy ±1%)

        • Mesa FlexCal Series (Volumetric Accuracy ±0.5%)

        • Mesa BGI DryCal Metrology Series

        • All Products

      • Accessories

        • Mesa Defender Series Accessories

        • Mesa FlexCal Series Accessories

        • Mesa DryCal Pro Software

      • Services

        • Equipment Calibration & Repair

      • Knowledge Center

        • Resource Library

        • Videos

        • FAQs

        • Customer Support

        • Request a Quote

      • Shop Online

    • Environmental Controls & Air Quality

      • Equipment

        • Mesa BGI Ambient Particulate Air Samplers

        • Mesa BGI Air Flow Calibrators

        • Mesa BGI Personal Sampling Cyclones

        • Mesa BGI Environmental Cyclones

        • All Products

      • Software

        • Mesa BGI Companion Software

      • Accessories

        • Environmental Accessories

        • Industrial Hygiene Accessories

        • Filter Media

      • Services

        • Equipment Calibration & Repair

        • Equipment Rental

      • Knowledge Center

        • Resource Library

        • Videos

        • FAQs

        • Customer Support

        • Request a Quote

      • Shop Online

    • Torque Testing

      • Products

        • Semi-Automatic Torque Testers

        • Manual Torque Testers

        • All Products

      • Accessories

        • Torque Testing Accesories

      • Software

        • TorqueIQ Process Control Software

      • Services

        • Gold Bottle Magnetic Torque Verification

        • Equipment Calibration & Repair

        • Upgrade/Trade-In Options

        • Torque Rentals

      • Knowledge Center

        • Resource Library

        • Customer Support

        • Request a Quote

  • About Us

    chevron
    • Our Purpose

    • Mesa Brand Family

    • Executive Team

    • Careers

    • Investor Information

  • Contact Us

  • Resource Library

    chevron
    • Certificate (COA) Finder

    • Regulatory Documents

    • Instruction Manuals

    • Product Specifications

    • Product Technical Reports

    • Safety Data Sheets

White Papers

  1. Home

  2. caret-right icon

    Our Solutions

  3. caret-right icon

    Sterilization & Cleaning Monitoring

  4. caret-right icon

    Knowledge Center

  5. caret-right icon

    White Papers

  6. caret-right icon

    VOL 11, ISSUE 3

VOL 11, ISSUE 3

Resistance Analysis of Mesophilic Spores to Ethylene Oxide Sterilization

By Beth Ridgeway

Occasionally a customer will contact us in a case where they have identified an organism in their biological indicator (BI) that is not the organism labeled on the Certificate of Analysis (CofA). Some of these situations arise when a customer streaks for isolation a cultured positive control, an unexpected positive that shows in their cycle, or during initial species identification for their in-house qualification testing. Most of the time the BIs in question are those containing mesophilic spores of Bacillus atrophaeus used in ethylene oxide (EtO) and dry heat sterilization processes. These BIs in particular will be the main focus of this Spore News. So, where did this contamination come from? Possible sources include, but are not limited to:

  • Improper aseptic technique when streaking or culturing the BI can lead to post-exposure contamination, i.e. the microbe came from the technician.
  • Environment; airborne microbes can contaminate the BI or the culture medium during the culturing process.
  • Non-sterile culture medium.
  • Contamination during the manufacturing process of the BIs.

Because the number of contaminating microbes is typically very low {under 10 colony forming units (CFUs)}, it is hard to ascertain an accurate count through plating techniques because of the presence of 106 spores of Bacillus atrophaeus on the BI. Bacillus atrophaeus does have an orange colony morphology which helps to differentiate this species from others that may be present. Again, the level is so low that in order to enumerate the contaminant, it is usually necessary to plate directly from a 10-1 dilution which means careful evaluation of the plates as this dilution factor will produce a lawn of Bacillus atrophaeus growth. Some users have tried enumerating or determining a percent contamination level by culturing a positive control (PC) and letting the PC proliferate. This is a very inaccurate assessment mainly because each organism has a different growth and death rate. This test is good for establishing whether another organism is present assuming strict aseptic technique was employed but should not be used to determine percent contamination. With all this being said, is contamination really an issue to the extent that it would negatively impact the intended performance of the BI? Let’s take a look at what the standards say regarding purity of the BI.

USP 37, General Chapters: <1035> BIOLOGICAL INDICATORS FOR STERILIZATION

‘‘Carriers and primary packaging shall not contain any contamination (physical, chemical, or microbial) that would adversely affect the performance or the stability characteristics of the biological indicator.”

USP 37, Monographs: Biological Indicators for Moist Heat, Dry Heat, and Gaseous Modes of Sterilization, Nonpaper Carriers

“Purity - There is no evidence of contamination with other microorganisms following examination of spores recovered from the carriers using a suitable plate culture medium.”

USP 37, Monographs: Biological Indicators for Ethylene Oxide Sterilization, Paper Carrier

‘‘Purity - By examination of the spores on a suitable plate culture medium, there is no evidence of contamination with other microorganisms.”

ANSI/AAMI/ISO 11138-1:2006, Sterilization of Health Care Products-Biological Indicators-Part 1: General Requirements

4.1.1 Quality systems

‘‘The manufacturer shall establish, document and maintain a formal quality system (e.g. ISO 13485, GMPs, or other national or regional requirements) to cover all operations required by this part of ISO 11138. In particular, the manufacturer shall take precautions at all stages of production to minimize contamination that would adversely affect the performance of the biological indicator.”

5.2 Carrier, primary and secondary packaging

5.2.1 ‘‘The materials of the carrier and the primary and secondary packaging shall not contain any contamination (physical, chemical or microbial) that would adversely affect the performance of the biological indicator.”

5.3 Inoculated carrier

5.3.2 ‘‘Only one strain of test organism shall be used in a batch of inoculated carriers, unless the manufacturer has demonstrated that the use of multiple strains does not significantly affect test organism per- formance in the specified sterilization process.”

When assessing the contamination issue, Mesa Labs believes that the contamination is typically not going to have a negative affect on the resistance performance of the BI. This is especially true if the contamination was picked up during the BI manufacturing process. If the contaminant was picked up through improper aseptic technique or airborne contamination when culturing, this poses a different kind of problem altogether, but does not necessarily negatively impact BI performance. When you look at it from a resistance performance standpoint, D-value is defined as, ‘‘the time or dose required to achieve inactivation of 90% of a population of the test microorganism under stated dose conditions”. Thus, consider a typical EtO BI that contains 1.0 x 106 spores of Bacillus atrophaeus and has a D-value of perhaps 3.5 minutes. Even if it were contaminated with 100 CFUs per BI and those contaminating microbes has a resistance that matched that of the test microorganism, the contaminant would be killed in the early stages of exposure with virtually zero potential to ‘‘out-survive” the test species.

The questions still arise though as to ‘‘what is the resistance of some of these organisms?” and ‘‘how do we know for sure that there is no impact on the resistance performance?”.

To assess this aspect, four different organisms were tested for ethylene oxide resistance. Two of the organisms, Bacillus cereus and Bacillus thuringiensis, were picked because they are commonly isolated spore forming contaminants. The two other organisms, Bacillus subtilis ‘‘5230” and Bacillus pumilus, were randomly chosen for no specific reason other than being two other mesophilic spore formers. For the testing, 4 batches of Strip BIs were manufactured with each of the four organisms using a 106 population. A population assay was performed on each batch and then fraction negative analysis using an ethylene oxide biological indicator evaluator resistometer (BIER) was performed using 10 units/exposure for each batch. The ten units from each batch were exposed in the same cycle. Units were then allowed to properly aerate and cultured into Tryptic Soy Broth (TSB) and incubated at 30°C - 35°C for 7 days. During the 7 days, data was recorded and post incubation D-values were calculated using the Stumbo Murphy Cochran method. These results are listed in Table 1.

Table 1: Ethylene Oxide Resistance of Mesophilic Spore

Organism Population D-value (in minutes)
Bacillus atrophaeus 2.7 x 106 3.8
Bacillus subtilis 5230 2.4 x 106 2.9
Bacillus cereus 3.5 x 106 2.0
Bacillus pumilus 3.0 x 106 3.7
Bacillus thuringiensis 3.1 x 106 1.6

 

Another test was performed to determine whether the presence of spores on the BI does have an effect on the resistance performance labeled on the CofA. Two organisms were chosen for this study, Bacillus cereus and Bacillus subtilis 5230. Bacillus atrophaeus MesaStrips were removed from the glassine and each strip was inoculated with 106 spores from each organism. Strips were allowed to dry overnight and then repackaged into glassine envelopes. Fraction negative analysis using an ethylene oxide (BIER) was performed using 10 units/exposure for each batch including MesaStrips only containing Bacillus atrophaeus. All batches were exposed in the same cycle. Units were then allowed to properly aerate and cultured into TSB and incubated at 30°C - 35°C for 7 days. During the 7 days, data was recorded and post incubation D-values were calculated using the Stumbo Murphy Cochran method. At the end of the 7 days, positive tubes from the longest cycle giving fractional data were streaked for isolation to confirm presence of only Bacillus atrophaeus, all plates indicated only Bacillus atrophaeus growth. Resistance performance is listed in Table 2.

Table 2: Resistance of Bacillus atrophaeus Strips Inoculated with Another Organism

BI configuration D-value (in minutes)
Bacillus atrophaeus only 3.8
Bacillus atrophaeus inoculated with 106 Bacillus cereus spores 3.9
Bacillus atrophaeus inoculated with 106 Bacillus subtilis 5230 spores 3.9

 

The data illustrated above reaffirms the position of Mesa Labs regarding purity and contamination. Of the organisms tested, all showed resistance below the resistance of Bacillus atrophaeus (data from Table 1). Even if the BIs were grossly contaminated with another organism, data from this study indicates there is negligible change to the overall resistance measurement as the data in Table 2 shows only a 0.1-minute increase to the measured D-value. It is worth noting that the purity acceptance criteria of Mesa Labs requires a level of ≤0.0001%. This equates to not more than one contaminating microbe for every one million test spores on the BI. From the data presented above, it is evident that this is a very reasonable and overly conservative acceptance level. Process controls are put in place during every step in the manufacture of the BI to assure that we are able to achieve this level of purity.

To summarize, if you find yourself asking any of the following questions, you should feel confident with the answers presented below.

‘‘Is my BI OK to use with these low levels of contamination?” Answer: Yes

‘‘Will it affect my process?” Answer: No

‘‘Am I in compliance with the guidelines set forth in the USP and ISO?” Answer: Yes

About the Author

Beth graduated from University of Montana with a B.S. in Microbiology and Medical Technology. She has worked for Mesa Labs for nine years holding positions in the BI production laboratory, Research and Development, and Contract Studies. Beth’s previous position was Spore Lab Supervisor and currently she is Director of Laboratory Production.

Topics: Ethylene Oxide ,   Failure Investigation ,   Resistance ,   Identification
Recent Posts
Why BIs Survive a Validated Cycle A Review of the Newly Released ISO 11138-8 Standard on the Validation of a Reduced Incubation Time for Biological Indicators Product D-Value Study - Part 2, Heat-sensitive & Atypical Aqueous Liquids Why perform a Product D-value Study? Part 1 The MeCo Solution: Improving Consistency, Accuracy and Robustness in SIP Validation Sub-culturing a Positive Biological Indicator for Identification Biological Indicators and the European Pharmacopoeia

Subscribe now

Full of expert takes on industry trends and the latest technical education offerings. Spore News gives you the insight you need to prepare for what's next.

MesaLabs

Our Solutions

  1. Sterilization & Cleaning Monitoring
  2. Mail-In Spore Testing
  3. Continuous & Process Monitoring
  4. Environmental Controls & Air Quality
  5. Occupational Health & Safety
  6. Renal Care Quality Control
  7. Torque Testing

About us

  1. Our Purpose
  2. Mesa Brand Family
  3. Executive Team
  4. Careers
  5. Investor Information
  1. Sterilization & Cleaning Monitoring
  2. Mail-In Spore Testing
  3. Continuous & Process Monitoring
  4. Environmental Controls & Air Quality
  5. Occupational Health & Safety
  6. Renal Care Quality Control
  7. Torque Testing
  1. Our Purpose
  2. Mesa Brand Family
  3. Executive Team
  4. Careers
  5. Investor Information
  1. Contact Us

    Corporate Headquarters
    Mesa Laboratories, Inc.
    12100 West 6th Ave.
    Lakewood, CO 80228

    303.987.8000
    customerservice@mesalabs.com

Connect with us

Follow us on Facebook Follow us on LinkedIn Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Facebook
©2022 Mesa Labs, Inc. All rights reserved. |   Terms, Conditions & Privacy Policy   |   Cookie Settings
©2022 Mesa Labs, Inc. All rights reserved. Terms, Conditions & Privacy Policy